I ate my own dog food and it was not so tasty

Over at Wisdump, Scrivs encouraged us a while ago to ‘eat your own dog food’ in the sense of using your site and seeing what it’s like. As many of you will have seen it’s been one of those insane months for me, not a bad thing (nope this isn’t a toooo busy to post post), however during this time I’ve also been eating some of my own dog food. No, we didn’t run out and decide puppy chow was the best option. Whilst doing the dog food test (I think that’s a great way to call it), I discovered one glaringly obvious thing. I actually don’t like this version of Diary of a website.

I am not saying I hate it, nope I am not some do one week then detest the next design freak - it takes at least 2 weeks often. I don’t hate it, to be honest that is one of the reasons for re-thinking it. It doesn’t give me any emotion and in my book that isn’t a good thing. I am not after people crying or buying my website flowers - this design has been featured in a fair few showcases, so I am not unhappy I did it. Overall people have received it well. However, again I appear to be my own worst critique in my decision.

There is a slight feeling of reluctance as a new flavour isn’t officially due out until january - yes, I am glad I have the flavour thing going on as my option when it comes to feeling like this about a design. I have even toyed with the option of putting on the second ever design of Diary of a website. I found it again the other day and actually felt more positive about it than this one. However, there are a few things I want sorted out on this site and I feel that before I move on those and add more functionality along with build on some I’ve not used to it’s fullest; I need to change the look of it.

Over at Simple bits and Avalonstar there is a far more dramatic site design going on. I’m not going to be removing all styling and putting up something from that point. Although, I do like that idea for motivating yourself to design. I am slowly working on the design for the next flavour which will be coconut.

There are a few reasons for choosing coconut. The first is that this site has gone through a fair few colours recently, a lot of them on the darker side. I feel it’s about time Diary of a website got a bit calmer and brighter. I am going to play my minimalist card with the next design in some respects. I doubt it will be a full on minimalist design, mine usually aren’t. I’ve been thinking a lot about content and this site I feel doesn’t deal with content as well as it could. I want to change that with the next flavour and focus on the way it’s presented.

All this being said, I’ve got to hold my hands up to a bit of a work load glut over the past month and as a result a lot of the changes that I had planned were put up but never followed through. The next flavour will be about making a point of using these and rather than just putting them up there actually doing something with them.

I have a pretty solid idea of what I am wanting to do, so don’t anticipate too long before the next flavour, I am also not being silly and committing myself to a date. I don’t want to rush anything as that won’t result in me being happy with the next flavour. I am not so unhappy I feel the need to put an old flavour on and feel that would actually de-motivate me. I always said that I would keep every flavour no matter what I felt, it’s up to you as the reader how you see this blog. I feel much happier for deciding to do an early flavour and to me that is important. I also hope it makes it better for you as the reader.


8 Responses to “I ate my own dog food and it was not so tasty”

I rebooted Nov. 1st and am now working through a complete redesign… sigh.

Just curious. What are some of the things that you have up but haven’t done much with?

I like the current site design you have except one thing… I like to read everything and was afraid I was missing something in the different sections.

But since I discovered that, I went to using a feed reader. This way it tells me when you have posted something new and I can click on the links.

Can’t wait to see the new flavor.

I tend to add things that I know I would be willing to use especially if it’s on other blogs. As much as I want to keep the old features, I know if I don’t bother with it after the first glance, I’d just remove them (eg. who uses a tagboard on their blogs these days?).

No drastic changes there though, I’m not good enough with design to start over. So it’s always tweak on the go and hopefully the readers will appreciate it from there.

One of the main new features was the forum. It’s aiming to be for the blog club revival and also for other things like colour and mood, design help and a few more bits.

I am not happy with the format of the content display either so this is going to be something I address. I don’t like the idea that anyone is ‘forced’ or feels the need to read my blog in any way - I’d rather you choose.

@Edrei yep the tag cloud on my blog is actually somethign I am thinking of getting rid of. I very rarely get any hits on it. The tags in the post are good as a category method and also work well for related posts, that seems to be about the maximum use around here though.

All blogs are generally a work in progress it seems, this is one of the reasons why I opted for flavours on my blog. It gives the opportunity for me to develop as I go and scratching the redesign itch ;) I also still like (despite not liking some of them) having the archive of flaovurs on this site.

I thought one of the items might have been the forum. I’ve clicked in a few times but hadn’t seen anything there yet.

I was against using a feed reader but the one I’m using (Sage for Firefox) lets me know when a blog has posted.

It would be nice to track if visitors are using the flavor choices and what their favorites are.

I am looking at this in vanilla flavour. It has to be my favourite - the type, spacing and general feel seems to fit DOAW in my opinion. I’m not saying I dislike the others - it’s just Vanilla seems right for this blog to me.

I’m a big fan of light on dark themes though - I guess I’m too old at 24 to appreciate all the dark designs. ;)

Can’t wait to see coconut. Keep up the good stuff.

@ Andrew : ye gods if you’re too old at 24 there’s no hope for me ;) Actually you aren’t alone from what I have seen vanilla and also the second one (not up here as pre-flavours and wordpress) were the most popular. Tracking flavours would be interesting, have to poke and see some way of doing that maybe beyond the feedback I’m using to base my current analysis on.

looking forward to it

I LOVE RYAN



Leave a Reply